That is a very great concern Ash, because that occurrence really have me personally as I 1st observed it, and that I cannot realize why the physician would abandon flower and Mickey with regard to some one he had in effect only recognized for one day.

The event truly didn’t band true for me personally. There seemed to be something which did not accumulate. Actually it is still one of my favourites considering the setting, the performing specifically from DT plus the tip behind the clockwork people.

But the tale if used into context making use of the whole period 2 arc simply did not appear to match.

I do not really know the solution and believe this may find some debate as different points from the episode being brought up recently.

I do believe truly, that I would like to take the see that his ‘experience’ with Reinette trigger him understand what flower could possibly offer. That maybe they performed start to get better. But whether he liked the lady. I personally don’t think he performed. In my opinion he previously an extremely deep, psychologically binding link with her. In my opinion she implied the planet to your. But I don’t consider he liked the woman. In my opinion it was nevertheless one step far from that.

I personally want to imagine the guy just cared for her very seriously. I cannot think of the medical practitioner ‘loving’ a companion. it’s just not correct.

Alone during the collection its founded that the Tardis would turn on crisis Programme anyone to capture Donna house if Doctor isn’t back in a lot of opportunity. It really is likely this is in position whenever TGitF is placed also and so the medical practitioner understands Mickey and flower is taken home and then he will just have to take the “slow course” to get to them.

The guy understands Reinette wasn’t slain by Clockwork Droids so he’s got accomplish all he is able to to truly save this lady and prevent record being messed with and trapping themselves for years and years is the best way he is able to accomplish that.

It can strike me though there ended up being meaningful hyperlink no pressing have to set Rose and Doctor 10.5 inside additional market, specifically since neither of these got a creature of that universe. Yes, it can has implied permanent separation from Jackie and Pete, but certainly that was flower’s alternatives to make, perhaps not the physician’s. As well as that issue, it might being easy adequate to request Pete together with infant to get to our very own market.

In my opinion there’s lots of truth as to what Steven Moffat said. “you need to give the physician credit for dumping a somewhat clingy girlfriend by staying her with a clone.”

The Moff said that?:D

I always loathed the thought of Doctor/Rose = OTP! therefore I chuckled quite difficult indeed whenever medical practitioner loaded the girl back off to this lady synchronous universe along with his homicidal clone on top of that.

It does strike myself though that there had been no pushing need certainly to create Rose and medical practitioner 10.5 within the different universe, especially since neither of them had been an animal of these universe. Yes, it would need meant long lasting divorce from Jackie and Pete, but certainly that was flower’s solution to produce, maybe not the Doctor’s. And also for that topic, it might are smooth enough to request Pete and kid to get to all of our market.

I believe there are many truth as to the Steven Moffat said. “You have to give the medical practitioner credit for dumping a slightly clingy girl by inserting the girl with a clone.”

I think he had been merely wanting to create just what he think ended up being just the right thing physically .. planning to render Rose and Doctor2 a chance and pleasure but also agonizing for your to witness Ten made that chance where he had been least very likely to run ..agree must have come flower’s preference most likely but this was Ten trying to create what the guy believe is most readily useful I think.got the guy gave Rose a selection she never ever will have kept your ..

Are intresting observe the triangle reunited when we find it in the specials…

SM’s comment about flower i always believe very dismissive of her-not certain the guy cares when it comes to dynamics ..

I planning Ten would not love due to the entire aging thing. We assumed he’d do the “slow course” before the time where Rose got so he could find the woman (together with Tardis) and continue their unique trip.

Doc#2 could love flower because he furthermore aged, so there was absolutely nothing to end your are with her. Thats why the guy could tell their (if thats what the guy whispered), where Doc#1 could not as it might possibly be too unpleasant.

Well i believe he adored flower. I mean, he had been planning to inform the girl in Doomsday.

Like you JessicaL, i am hoping we get observe all of them back in the deals

Yeah I do believe he did, I believe he however do, but like the medical practitioner himself states, the companions can living her everyday lives with your (which surprisingly we have been however to see) but the guy can’t live their together.

Therefore including, when flower only attempted to move ahead.

I really could think that RTD was pushing a “Doctor crazy” story that not all of the authors assented with so that whilst RTD is trying to shoehorn such a land arc to the store people had been writing reports that smashed they to items (like SM with GITF).

Do i believe 10 adored the woman, well yes i do believe The Doctor is extremely no-cost together with prefer and his awesome relationship. yet not as “the passion for his lives”.

After his post-Time conflict dark-and-lonely-period as 9 I believe that 10 reacted by heading too far another ways and certain himself that just what he demanded were to settle down with a good woman. Unfortunately the guy cannot get a hold of an effective lady very certain themselves that a rather average looking blond chav would do alternatively